Target Species

Redfish Fishing in Pine Island

The bull red. Copper-bronze flanks, that unmistakable black eye spot near the tail, and a bulldog fight that never quits.

Quick Answer

Redfish in Pine Island are a year-round target, though fall brings the best action as fish stage for spawning. They're found on the grass flats, around mangrove points, and in the deep cuts between islands. A 7- or 8-weight fly rod is the tool of choice, and these fish will eat a well-presented crab or shrimp pattern without hesitation.

How We Fish

Redfish

Redfish, also known as red drum, are the backbone of inshore fly fishing in Southwest Florida. They're opportunistic feeders with a strong preference for crustaceans—crabs and shrimp make up the bulk of their diet, though they'll crush a baitfish when the opportunity arises. Their distinctive black spot, located on the upper portion of the tail, is present on nearly every fish and serves as their signature marking.

In the Pine Island area, redfish occupy a range of habitats. The shallow grass flats provide sight-fishing for smaller school fish, while the deeper mangrove shorelines and channel edges hold larger bulls. The key to consistent success is reading the water—redfish relate to structure, whether it's a mangrove point, a dock pilings, or a subtle change in bottom composition.

Fall is arguably the best season, as redfish begin staging near inlets and passes for their spawn. This concentrates fish in larger numbers and brings the bigger bulls out of the deep water. However, quality fish are caught year-round, and the winter months offer more comfortable conditions on the water.

Redfish Fishing FAQ

What's the best tide for redfish?
Moving water is key. Redfish feed most actively as the tide changes—either coming in or going out. A rising tide pushing water over the flats into the mangroves is often the prime scenario.
What flies work best for redfish?
Crab patterns and shrimp patterns are the go-to choices. Tan, olive, and chartreuse colors all produce well. Match the hatch to local forage, and don't be afraid to fish subsurface.
Are redfish good to eat?
Redfish are excellent table fare, with firm white flesh that flakes well. Slot limits apply in Florida—slot fish are the best eating size anyway.
Book your trip with Rescue Fly Charters today.

Ready to Get on the Water?

Dates fill up fast in season. Reach out to Rescue Fly Charters to lock in your charter.