Where We Fish

Fishing Guide in Sanibel

Sanibel Island is famous for shells, but the fishing here is just as impressive once you get away from the beach crowds.

On the Water

Fishing Sanibel

Fishing Sanibel means working some of the most unique water in the region. The island creates a barrier between the Gulf and the back bays, and the fishing ranges from surf fishing along the Gulf side to shallow bay fishing in the backcountry. As a guide, I focus on the bay side, where the grass flats and mangrove islands hold good populations of snook, redfish, and pompano that move in with the seasonal migrations. The Gulf side can be productive when conditions align, particularly in spring when mackerel and kingfish push through, but the real consistent action is in the protected waters behind the island. Sanibel also offers excellent fishing around the lighthouse and the eastern tip, where the current from the sound creates ambush points for predatory fish. The challenge here is that the island draws a lot of visitors, so timing and local knowledge help me find less pressured water.

Trip Options

4 HoursUp to 2 anglers
550/ trip

Half Day

  • All fly gear available or bring your own
  • Flies, leaders and tippet
  • Bottled water and ice
1 more detail
  • Florida saltwater fishing license for the day
Recommended
6 HoursUp to 2 anglers
750/ trip

6 Hour

  • All fly gear available or bring your own
  • Flies, leaders and tippet
  • Bottled water, ice and snacks
1 more detail
  • Florida saltwater fishing license for the day
8 HoursUp to 2 anglers
850/ trip

Full Day

  • All fly gear available or bring your own
  • Flies, leaders and tippet
  • Bottled water, ice, snacks and lunch
1 more detail
  • Florida saltwater fishing license for the day

Important information

What We Provide

  • A boat rigged and ready for the day's fishing
  • Rods, reels, and tackle for every angler
  • All bait, ice, and terminal tackle
  • Your fishing license for the day
  • Bottled water and cold drinks
  • A licensed captain who knows the water

What to Bring

  • Sunglasses, sunscreen & a hat
  • Food and drinks in a soft cooler
  • Weather-appropriate clothing and a light jacket
  • Non-marking, closed-toe shoes
  • Your camera — and a sense of adventure
Have a custom trip in mind? Call and we'll set it up.

Fishing Sanibel with Rescue Fly Charters

Local Knowledge

We know Pine Island waters and how the bite changes with the season and conditions.

On the Water Daily

Based in Pine Island and running trips all season long.

All Experience Levels

From first-timers and kids to seasoned anglers, we tailor the trip to your crew.

5.0★ Google Rating

Rated 5.0 out of 5 on Google from 6 reviews.

Rated 5 stars on Google

What Anglers Say

Captain Stuart gave me an incredible experience! Between the knowledge of the local waters & great communication, I would highly recommend taking a trip with Captain Stu. He was able to get me to land this 27" slot Red!! Biggest one I've ever caught! Great experience & great…
Baylie Eikmeier
Verified Google Review
Great experience. Wonderful guide. Amazing day! Definitely recommend!
Diva Padilla
Had a Blast with Captain Stu! Caught a bunch of trout and my first snook in a long time. My buddy Derrick even jumped a 75 pound tarpon. We had a Blast Definitely will book another trip
Antonio Joseph
Amazing trip with cap Stu! I didn’t get a big fish into the boat, but I did land my first snook on the fly, and that alone made the day a win. Great time on the water and I’d absolutely book again.
Derrick Dawson
I had a great time yesterday on the water with Capt. Stu. He took me on an all day trip and did not disappoint. Got me my first redfish and tarpon which we leadered to the boat and he shoot back off under the boat and broke us off. To top it off that got me my first inshore…
Matt Christ
Had an excellent time the guy seems real knowledgeable about the fish in the area and everything going on with the fishery. Would def go again!
JC Drye

Fishing Sanibel FAQ

Is Sanibel good for surf fishing?
The Gulf beaches hold fish, especially in spring, but it requires different techniques than bay fishing.
What is the best time to fish Sanibel?
Fall and spring are prime seasons, with summer being productive but requiring early morning starts.
Do I need to worry about red tide on Sanibel?
I monitor conditions closely and will adjust our fishing location if needed to ensure a safe, enjoyable trip.
Book your trip with Rescue Fly Charters today.

Ready to Get on the Water?

Dates fill up fast in season. Reach out to Rescue Fly Charters to lock in your charter.

Redfish in a fishing photo from Rescue Fly Charters